The median home value in Palmyra, NY is $167,000.
This is
lower than
the county median home value of $187,900.
The national median home value is $338,100.
The average price of homes sold in Palmyra, NY is $167,000.
Approximately 66.22% of Palmyra homes are owned,
compared to 29.87% rented, while
3.92% are vacant.
Palmyra real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Palmyra real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Prime location, Solid mechanics, needs TLC, High traffic location.
Fairytale Cape Cod on over an acre in Palmyra The perfect country home is waiting for you at the end of this winding long driveway into the woods. Look out the huge windows onto a park-like backyard perfect for gatherings, gardening, or enjoying the history and nature around the Erie canal. A quick 20 minutes straight down route 31 to Perinton, you’re conveniently close to everything with the privacy and peace hidden away at the end of your private 150ft+ driveway. Park at your toys in your HUGE 2.5 car metal-roof garage with extra storage! Spacious and inviting layout with a huge primary bedroom with ensuite on the main floor. Perfect layout for single-story living with flex and guest bedroom options on the first or second floor. Natural light flows throughout the open layout of the family and living room. Modern skylights, appliances, and energy-efficient mechanics. Most updates in the last ten years! Septic tank installed 2014, water heater 2020, and new electric service installed 2023 Unique story about the “core” of this home! The center section was originally a gift shoppe at the end of the road, pulled back and reimagined as a country retreat. You see historic elements of the original square footage peeking out in the airy loft’s wide-plank 1800’s floors and authentic shiplap. Charming country kitchen has updated solid surface counters and extra deep cabinets. Fresh luxury floors and paint throughout. Efficiently heated with forced air oil furnace or with a luxury soapstone wood-burning stove. It’s the perfect size cozy space for all seasons! Open Houses: Thursday, November 21st, 4:00 PM - 6:00 PM Saturday, November 23rd, 11:00 AM - 1:00 PM Don’t wait to see this one! Offers Due Tuesday November 26 at 4:00PM
This Showplace Brick two family is nestled in the Historic Palmyra Village offering walkable distances to schools, parks, uptown and the renowned Palmyra Community Center! With over 3500 Sq. Ft. of elegant living space, the options are endless! The current owners side offers 2 full baths, a First floor laundry and a beautiful Family room addition opening to a 3 season room. The open concept kitchen boasts recent SS appliances and two areas for dining and gathering. The neighbor friendly covered front porch is built of low maintenance composite. Each side offers 3 bedrooms, separate entrances and utilities. **NO DELAYED NEGOTIATIONS, DONT DELAY ON THIS ONE!**
This UPDATED colonial is LOADED WITH CHARACTER! Natural woodwork and refinished hardwoods greet you as you enter the spacious livingroom. The open concept, updated kitchen features NEWER STAINLESS APPLIANCES! Hardwoods continue throughout the first floor! RECENTLY RENOVATED FIRST FLOOR FULL BATH! An additional room, perfect for a family room or formal dining room completes the first floor. NEW carpet heading upstairs and in all bedrooms! The MASSIVE primary boasts a large closet with built in organizer unit and FULL BATH! Two additional spacious bedrooms complete the second floor. Enjoy time outside on the front porch, back patio and in the large yard. Plenty of storage inside in the full basement and outside in the shed. FRESH PAINT in most of home! UPDATED MECHANICS include Tear off roof (2019), Hot water tank (2021), furnace (2014) and 200 amp service. Delayed negotiations on file. Offers due Monday, 11/25 @ 5 PM. Welcome HOME!
This multi use property is located in the heart of Palmyra! 3 Story brick building with 2 storefronts and 4 one bedroom apartments. Plenty of parking on the street and 3 spots that are reserved for the property itself. There is also a municipal parking lot at the rear of the building. The interior is in need of rehab and has been started. No delayed negotiations, please give 24 hours for response to offers. Endless possibilities for a new owner!
Charming ranch home on over 1 acre, located on low-traffic Hansen Street! Enjoy an open-concept living room with vaulted ceilings and a kitchen with granite countertops. The owner's suite includes a full bath and walk-in closet. Spacious dining room with a cozy gas fireplace. Enclosed rear patio with scenic views of the historic Erie Canal and Canal Trail. Central A/C! First floor laundry. Open House on Sunday 11/10 from 12pm-2pm. Delayed negotiations Tuesday 11/12 at 3pm.
Investor special! This two-story property on nearly 3 acres in Palmyra, NY, 14522, is priced to sell and brimming with potential. While it needs significant cleanup and repairs, it offers a rare opportunity for investors and flippers to transform it into a valuable asset. Enjoy a private, nature-filled setting just off a major road, with convenient access to local amenities, schools, and charming downtown Palmyra. This expansive parcel opens the door to endless possibilities—don’t miss your chance to make it your next project! # BR is owner verified.
Nestled in the charming village of Palmyra, this cozy 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath ranch is ready for your personal touch! With solid mechanics in place, this home offers the perfect foundation for those willing to put in a little blood, sweat, and equity. Featuring a classic one-level layout, this property provides a great opportunity for first-time buyers or savvy investors looking to customize their dream home. Don’t miss the chance to transform this well-built house into the perfect space, right in the heart of Palmyra. Don’t miss the opportunity to invest in a property with incredible potential! Don't forget to ask us about renovation program! This property is being offered with our custom renovation program; you make the selections, we do the work! Get ready to move into your new home the way you dreamed it!
Many corn/soybean producers have the capacity to dry their grain themselves- if your farm does not then this is a great opportunity for you and others to share this parcel as a coop! Conveniently located right near the CSX tracks in Palmyra NY! The OVERSIZED TEN THOUSAND gallon propane tank gives you the opportunity to purchase LP in bulk- saving you thousands over time! The AIR CONDITIONED and HEATED OFFICE space (with a restroom) has plenty of counter/storage and workspace! The LARGE SIZED - TOP OF THE LINE- TRUCK SCALE has its own BUILDING with oversized windows for a great view of the parcel. There’s a drive over conveyor for QUICK and EASY unloading - over 200,000 bushel STORAGE capacity and MULTIPLE grain legs make a great co-op drying facility for you OR other farmers! Currently 3 phase electric (3-Phase power is absolutely helpful for heavier electrical loads, whether it's a large office building or a factory) and many updates including fans, chains and motors!
Stately 19th century colonial on over 3 acres with room for everyone! Almost 3000 square feet with 5 bedrooms and 2 full baths, as well as other rooms that could accommodate an in-home office or game room. The layout is conducive to in-law or multi-generational living with a first floor bedroom and bathroom in close proximity. Great features you'd expect in a home of this vintage like 10' high ceilings, open staircase just inside the front door, a separate set of stairs off the kitchen and a large, sun-lit pantry. There's even an unfinished post and beam room right off the kitchen teasing your imagination and a lovely sun porch on the other side of the house. This home has been well maintained and upgraded with modern electrical service, radiant heat, a tear-off roof and public water. Out back a small stream meanders past an old pig barn and chicken coop. The acreage is a nice mix of dense woods and open areas connected by a trail. Quick possession possible. Call today!
Are you looking for a large updated home with mid century modern style nestled on 1.75 private, parklike property with scenic views? This 4 bedroom 3 bath home features a large, updated eat in kitchen with stainless appliances and hardwood floors, and large bay window to view your property while enjoying dinner or having your morning cup of coffee. Large living room and family room for entertaining with balconies and patios and a hot tub too! Master bedroom with large master suite with radiant heated floors and large vanity. 2 additional bedrooms on first floor with 2nd full bath. Down to finished walk out basement with large fieldstone fireplace and built in bar. This is truly a unique property with beautiful park like views , lots of light, and a great location with quick access to the canal!
Escape to this delightful cottage situated right on the serene waters of the Erie Canal. Perfectly set up for relaxing, this home boasts a brand-new heating system and updated insulation, ensuring comfort in every season. Inside, you'll find a beautifully renovated interior that seamlessly blends modern conveniences with timeless charm. Step outside onto the spacious deck, where you can relax and take in the peaceful surroundings—it's the perfect spot for morning coffee, evening sunsets, boating, or fishing. Located just a short drive from nearby towns, this cottage offers the ultimate retreat with easy access to all your essential provisions. Whether you're seeking a tranquil getaway or a cozy residence, this property offers the peace and quiet you deserve.
This wonderful vacant property has it all rolling hills, wooded forest and enough agricultural to qualify for the Ag Exemption. Great location and tons of privacy, perfect for all the recreational and hunting activities as well as a potentially specatular building location. Raw land, but many of the utilities at the road. The frontage on N. Creek Road is roughly indicate by two two-foot orange stakes.
WELCOME TO AN EXCEPTIONAL OPPORTUNITY! THIS EXPANSIVE COMMERCIAL BUILDING OFFERS MORE THAN 12,OOO SQ.FT ON TWO LEVELS PERFECTLY SITUATED TO ACCOMODATE DIVERSE BUSINESS VENTURES! WITH ATTRACTIVE OFFICES OR STORE FRONT ON STATE HIGHWAY 31, IT CAN ASSURE YOUR BUSINESS VENTURE MAXIMUN EXPOSURE WITH THE HIGH VOLUME OF TRAFFIC. THE BUILDING'S DESIGN CAN ALSO ACCOMODATE CAR DEALERSHIP FLOOR LOADINGS WHILE OFFERING GENEROUS CLEAR SPANS FOR MAXIMUN FLEXIBILITY. THE LOWER LEVEL HAS 5 GARAGE BAYS, IN EXCESS OF 12 ' CEILINGS AND EXTENSIVE STORAGE WITH ADDITIONAL OFFICE AREAS. THIS ATTRACTIVE BRICK FACADE BUILDING ON THE ENTRANCE TO THIS QUAINT HISTORIC VILLAGE IS SITUATED ON 1.46 ACRES ZONED TO PROVIDE A WIDE VARIETY OF COMMERCIAL USES INCLUDING MOTOR VEHICLE SALES, AUTOMOBILE REPAIR, RETAIL SALES & OFFICES. WITH MORE THAN SIX PRIVATE OFFICES, SEVEN BATHROOMS, A FULL KITCHEN, 2 OPEN AREA SHOWROOMS AND THE FULL LOWER LEVEL,THE POSSIBILITIES ARE ENDLESS! PERFECT OPPORTUNITY FOR USER OCCUPANT THAT NEEDS OFFICE/FLEX SPACE WITH STORAGE! THRUWAY ACCESS WITHIN 15 MINUTES IS AN ADDED BONUS!