Cicero IN Homes for Rent

The median home value in Cicero, IN is $365,000. This is lower than the county median home value of $387,100. The national median home value is $338,100. The average price of homes sold in Cicero, IN is $365,000. Approximately 76.72% of Cicero homes are owned, compared to 19.71% rented, while 3.57% are vacant. Cicero real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Cicero real estate agent to arrange a tour today!


Sort Results:
1–20 of 20 properties displayed
Refine Property Search
Page 1 of 1    Prev | Next
Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,440
Status:
NEW LISTING
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.18 Acres
Year built:
2004
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
22001066
Subdivision:
Greystone Village

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Cicero!! You will love this amazing community with the small town charm and minutes to Morse Lake. The 3 Bedroom, 2 bath Ranch home is waiting on a new owner to make it their own. this home has so much potential with the Open Floorplan, Large Primary bedroom with walk-in closet, Spacious Living room and Kitchen. All Appliances included. Just steps to the Walking path that will connect to the Downtown Cicero, all the restaurants, shops! Check out the Public lake access at Red Bridge Park for kayaking and fishing.You will love all the Cicero Festivities and the 4th of July fireworks over the Lake.

Type:
Manufactured Home
Sq.Ft.:
1,062
Status:
NEW LISTING
Beds:
2
Lot size:
0.13 Acres
Year built:
1977
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
22011803
Subdivision:
Hidden Bay

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

BEAUTIFUL, NEWLY RENOVATED HOME located in a quiet cul de sac - just steps from Morse Reservoir and your favorite local shops and restaurants in downtown Cicero! This amazing move-in ready home has a bright and open concept layout showcasing the modern kitchen, with eat-in bar, and lots of cabinet space. New kitchen appliances make it ready for home cooked meals and entertaining. You've got to see it to believe it. The great room stretches into the living room, dining room, and kitchen. It is an expansive space with recessed lighting throughout, new flooring and fresh paint. Extra special finishes make this an exceptional home. It is inviting, warm, and welcoming. Both big bedrooms have new carpet and great windows with wood trim to brighten up the rooms. 2 new bathrooms each have ceramic tiled floors and showers with rain heads. Great covered front porch, RV hookup, and large storage shed offer all the conveniences for lake life, which include fishing, kayaking, swimming, boating! You will love the mature trees and outdoor life in a quaint community. Lakefront restaurants within walking distance! This special piece of property is also an INVESTOR'S DREAM! Excellent opportunity to get in on a lake home at a remarkable price!

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,407
Status:
NEW LISTING
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.2 Acres
Year built:
1900
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
22011697
Subdivision:
Dunhams

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

This beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home blends historic charm with modern convenience, offering a welcoming and versatile space for its next owner. The enclosed front porch, complete with a swing and additional seating, adds character and opens to a spacious, inviting great room. The stainless kitchen features Craftsman-style cabinetry, a pantry, quartz countertops, a coffee and breakfast bar, and an adjacent breakfast room. A versatile dining or flex room, complete with built-in cabinetry, offers endless possibilities. The main-level primary and guest bedrooms, along with the upper-level bedroom and adjacent office or nursery, provide flexible living options for everyone. Sleek, tiled bathrooms add a dramatic touch, while the laundry room, equipped with a washer and dryer, balances style and functionality. You'll love the heated all-seasons room, the herringbone paver patio with a fire pit, and the fully fenced yard - perfect for entertaining or relaxation. Just blocks from Morse Reservoir, this home offers easy access to Cicero's best amenities and waterfront experiences. Red Bridge Park, with its marina and scenic trails, is a short stroll away, while Jackson Street provides a vibrant corridor of local eateries and shops with a variety of dining options. Convenient access to SR-31 and SR-19 makes traveling a breeze. With contemporary colors, warm-toned flooring, recessed lighting, thermal, double-hung windows, complete with blinds, an ample garage, and plenty of storage, there's nothing missing but you!

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,606
Status:
NEW LISTING
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.38 Acres
Year built:
1976
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
22011461
Subdivision:
Cicero Shores

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome home to this immaculate lake house situated on a huge corner lot (.38 acres) nestled on Morse Reservoir in the quaint town of Cicero! Fall in love with the wonderful outdoor amenities overlooking the water including a firepit & two levels of entertaining space. Boat dock (dock #283) with canopy & automatic lift. Relax on the all weather deck off the back of the home with a storage shed built underneath for all your yard and/or boating storage needs! The home offers 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, two living spaces, gas fireplace, dining room & kitchen with 2 pantries. All appliances included in the sale. The current owners have lovingly cared for the home for the past 29 years & pride of ownership shines throughout. New seawall 2016, roof 2021, HVAC 2022, fresh paint and new carpet 2024. Short walk to the park with pickleball courts & a quick golf cart ride to all that downtown Cicero has to offer! Come take a look today & be ready for boating season come Spring!

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,471
Status:
Active
Beds:
2
Lot size:
0.13 Acres
Year built:
2021
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
22006696
Subdivision:
Tamarack

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome Home to the Lakeside Community of Cicero Indiana. Walking Distance to Morse Reservoir! You will love this spacious 2 Bedroom, 2 bath, Villa Ranch home in the desirable Tamarack neighborhood in Cicero! Shows like a Model Home and Move-in ready! This is Low-maintenance living at its BEST! Fantastic Location just blocks to Red Bridge Park, Kayak Launch On Morse, Fishing, Downtown Restaurants and Shops. Awesome Features include a Split bedroom floorplan, Bright and Open Kitchen with Large Center island and Breakfast area, Primary bedroom with a gorgeous bath with Double sinks, Walk-in shower and a Large walk-in closet. Second bedroom w/adjacent full bath. Large laundry room plus that extra storage room that you need. Finished 2 car attached garage. Relax on the Darling covered Front porch or sit out back under your spacious covered Veranda! All Appliances included! Golf Cart Friendly Community! Welcome Home.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,716
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.3 Acres
Year built:
1950
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
22009371
Subdivision:
Dunhams

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

FULLY REMODELED 3 BED / 3 FULL BATH 2 STORY on HUGE FENCED (6 FT SHADOWBOX) PRIVATE LOT just steps away from DOWNTOWN CICERO! REMODEL JUST COMPLTED AND this 1700+SF BEAUTY is ready for its NEW OWNERS to move right in!! SPACIOUS FAMILY ROOM w/ NEW FLOORING, LIGHTING & FIXTURES THRU-OUT! RECONFIGURED KITCHEN W/ NEW CABS, COUNTERS & APPLs! ALL BATHROOMS HAVE BEEN OVERHAULED w/ NEW SHINY FINISHES! LAUNDRY ROOM / MUD ROOM ADDED AS WELL! NEW ROOF & GUTTERS! FRESH PAINT INSIDE & OUT! COME SEE!!

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,471
Status:
Active
Beds:
2
Lot size:
0.13 Acres
Year built:
2019
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
22006101
Subdivision:
Tamarack

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Enjoy low-maintenance living in Indiana's premier lakeside community of Cicero! This 2 bedroom, 2 bath charmer has been meticulously cared for and boasts an ample primary suite with walk-in closet, large step-in shower and dual sinks. Nicely appointed kitchen with breakfast area and includes all stainless-steel appliances. Luxury vinyl plank throughout the common areas. Laundry can be accessed directly from the primary bedroom and includes washer and dryer! Enjoy summer evenings on your covered patio. 2 car garage with overhead storage added. All lawn maintenance and snow-removal is included with the HOA dues. Tamarack has neighborhood pool for residents to enjoy along with a playground. Drive your golf cart to town to enjoy the local shops and eateries as well as Morse Lake activities.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,652
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
0.26 Acres
Year built:
2020
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
22006079
Subdivision:
Tamarack

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome to this over 2600 sq ft. spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home in the desirable Tamarack Subdivision in Cicero! With a bright living room and a cozy family room filled with natural light, this home offers comfort and style. The family room flows effortlessly into the open-concept kitchen and dining area, creating the perfect space for entertaining. The kitchen features a large island, stainless steel appliances, and a built-in coffee bar for added convenience. All bedrooms are located upstairs, offering privacy and easy access to a versatile loft area, ideal for additional living space. The second-floor laundry room makes chores more convenient. Situated on a large corner lot, this property provides a generous yard, perfect for outdoor gatherings, kids, and pets. Don't miss the chance to make this home yours-schedule a showing today! This house is in the beautiful town of Cicero, offering residents a blend of comfort and convenience. Enjoy recreational paths, sidewalks, a bathhouse, neighborhood pool, and a playground, perfect for both relaxation and outdoor fun, With quick access to downtown Cicero, the Morse Reservoir, schools, churches, and a variety of excellent restaurants and shopping options, you will have everything you need right at your doorstep. The town is also renowned for its fantastic Parks and Recreation areas, including the Cicero Community Park, the Red Bridge Community Park and Marina, and the Strawtown Koteewi Park. The 750-acre Strawtown Koteewi Park features a canoe launch on the White River, boating and fishing opportunities, nature trails for hiking and cycling, equestrian trails, and beautiful wetlands and prairies. Cicero is also a popular destination for cycling enthusiasts, offering scenic routes and a welcoming community for outdoor adventures. Cicero is ideally located near communities such as Westfield, Noblesville, Kokomo, Anderson, and Indianapolis, providing a peaceful suburban lifestyle with easy access to major HWY's

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
4,204
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
10.93 Acres
Year built:
2007
Baths:
4.00
MLS#:
22005606
Subdivision:
Subdivision Not Available See Legal

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

This stunning 10.93-acre property, located in Charming Cicero*, offers over 4,200 sq. ft. of finished living space-ideal for those seeking tranquility & the potential for equestrian use. The homestead is one of 5 parcels in this quiet neighborhood and features 4BR, including the Primary Bedroom ensuite with double vanity, 2 large walk in closets, waterfall jacuzzi, separate shower & private entry, spacious Den & 3.5BA. The open-concept layout is perfect for family living & entertaining. A grand, 20ft, floor-to-ceiling two-sided stone fireplace welcomes you & all who visit. Additionally, the gorgeous 20ft picture windows & sliding French doors, frame the mature tree lines & expansive & private lot, allowing you to enjoy breathtaking sunrises & sunsets. The partially finished-full lower level includes a newly completed BR, media room, & full BA and walkout access with ample space to add a rec room, bar, or gym, along with other versatile living areas. The foundation is by Superior Walls, a custom precast concrete foundation. Outdoors, you'll find a unique She-Shed, divided to serve as both a storage shed & a hobby space...plus a fire pit. While not currently set up for horses, the property offers plenty of potential for equestrian use. This home offers new owners opportunity to update and personalize to their personal likeness. The roof is new as of Aug '24 and New geothermal in Oct '22. Priced to sell "As Is" but inspection is welcomed. Conveniently located and just 5 minutes from Morse Lake, 12 minutes from shopping & dining at Clay Terrace area, easy access to medical & more, plus only 45 minutes from Indianapolis International Airport. This estate strikes the perfect balance between rural charm & modern convenience, with soon-to-be easy access to 31. Schedule a tour today to explore all the possibilities this exceptional property has to offer! *NOTE- the property tax records can be found under the property previously named address- 4307 236th St, Cicero, IN.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,412
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.15 Acres
Year built:
2007
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
22005027
Subdivision:
Warehams Pond

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

The house of your dreams is waiting for you now! Snuggled into Cicero's golf cart community this 3 bdrm 2 bath ranch with a huge deck backing up to the city's park system is waiting for you in the heart of Cicero. Get active. Step out of your yard into the city walking trails, baseball fields, festival area, community gazebo, concerts and the 4th of July Celebration, tennis & pickle ball courts, a playground for the littles and Cicero Library a short walk away. And this Premium Lot will never have homes built behind it. So, fire up the grill & practice some pitch with friends while the charcoal gets hot! Or relax in the evening shade and watch the clouds float by - because, YES! This is a Big Sky Home! Inside, you'll have a cozy, open floor plan with a kitchen overlooking the family room and separate dining room! You'll also see: NEW ROOF, CARPET, BACK DOOR, GARBAGE DISPOSAL, REFINISHED DECK, NEWER water heater, refrigerator and LOW TAXES. This home has a lot going for it that you won't find anywhere else. The 2 car attached garage has a sturdy built in shelf system and fridge. The Fire Department is next door to the neighborhood. Cicero restaurants are popular for miles around. I've included a photo taken from the deck at the Boathouse Restaurant. And if you like stress free Sunday drives with beautiful views, grab your bikes or pile in the car and drive in any direction! Come today and see!

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
1,768
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
0.25 Acres
Year built:
1990
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
22002294
Subdivision:
Cicero Shores

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome to this meticulously maintained 4-bedroom, 2-story home in the charming golf cart community of Cicero, Indiana. Nestled in a peaceful neighborhood, this residence offers a perfect blend of modern comfort and timeless appeal. As you enter, you're greeted by natural light from large windows through the home highlighting the functional floor plan of the home. The inviting living room flows seamlessly into the well-appointed kitchen, complete with stainless steel appliances, ample cabinetry, and pantry. The main floor also features a formal dining area that overlooks the beautifully landscaped front yard, creating a serene dining experience. A convenient half-bath and a dedicated laundry room round out this level. Upstairs, you'll find four generously sized bedrooms, each offering plenty of closet space and comfortable carpeted flooring. Step outside to discover a meticulously maintained backyard, complete with a spacious patio perfect for summer barbecues and outdoor gatherings. The lush lawn and large trees offer a tranquil space to relax complete with a shed for storage. Additional features include a two-car garage with bump out and a well-maintained exterior with charming curb appeal. This home is just minutes from local parks, shopping, and numerous dining options, most of which is accessible by the walking path just steps from the home. Whether its pickle ball or kayaking, both are possible in friendly lakeside town of Cicero. Don't miss the opportunity to make this stunning home yours! 1/89 ownership in the common area located on the west side of Stringtown Pike across from the south entrance of Lincoln drive. The common area features large lot as well as lake access for fishing or swimming.

Type:
Manufactured Home
Sq.Ft.:
1,344
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
2 Acres
Year built:
1988
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
21998254
Subdivision:
No Subdivision

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Looking to own a piece of coveted Hamilton County land? This prime 2 acre property less than 5 minutes from both US 31 & Cicero offers a unique opportunity. Older 3bd/2ba manufactured home in need of repair rests on a permanent foundation. Oversized attached 2 car garage provides lots of storage possibilities. Septic has been pumped and new riser installed. Brand new well pump. With some elbow grease and a little vision, this is a rare opportunity to capture some sweat equity on some of the most valuable dirt in the state of Indiana. Sold As-Is. Cash offers only.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,091
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
5.69 Acres
Year built:
2019
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
21999607
Subdivision:
No Subdivision

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Welcome to your private retreat nestled on just under 6 acres of serene, heavily wooded land-a true hidden gem! This charming, nearly new, 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath ranch home offers the perfect blend of modern comfort and natural tranquility. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by a spacious living room with stunning cathedral ceilings that create an open and airy ambiance. The heart of the home features a well-appointed kitchen and dining area, perfect for entertaining or enjoying family meals. The master suite provides a peaceful haven with its own private bath and two closets, while the additional bedrooms offer versatility for guests or a growing family. Step outside to discover a covered back patio, where you can unwind and take in the breathtaking views of your wooded oasis. The full 9' basement offers ample storage or the potential for customization to fit your needs. Plus, a generous 4-car garage provides plenty of space for vehicles, tools, and hobbies. This property offers the ultimate in privacy and seclusion while still being conveniently close to local amenities. Whether you're sipping your morning coffee or hosting a summer barbecue, this space is ideal for relaxation and enjoying nature.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
3,884
Status:
Active
Beds:
5
Lot size:
0.3 Acres
Year built:
1986
Baths:
4.00
MLS#:
21997776
Subdivision:
Morse Landing

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Own Your Dream Lakefront Home on Morse Reservoir. Move-in ready and stunning, this Morse Reservoir home offers a walk-out basement with all-new luxury vinyl plank flooring and fresh paint. Enjoy the convenience of a flat backyard with no steep steps to navigate, leading you to your small beach and private covered boat dock with a lift. The current 22-foot boat is negotiable. Entertain in style on the expansive 52-foot deck overlooking the serene lake, perfect for enjoying your morning coffee or watching beautiful sunsets. Inside, this spacious home features 5 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, boasting granite countertops and Brazilian teak hardwood floors. Recent updates include luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout the main and upper levels, new windows, stylish back doors with a picturesque window in the living room, and a newly renovated owner's retreat with a walk-in shower and tile floors. The recently updated roof and skylights provide natural light year-round.

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
3,072
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
0.35 Acres
Year built:
1976
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
21995305
Subdivision:
Cicero Shores

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

This wonderful lakefront home on Morse Reservoir was rebuilt from ground up 3 years ago. Everything is new! With 4BR 3BA's this home has a multitude of features. Gourmet kitchen with high end commercial appliances and large island with room for 5 people to eat at. Gorgeous Primary bedroom with double walk in closets, well done walk in shower, double sinks, stand alone tub exudes comfort. To add to the primary BR a great Trex deck is entered on to from the Primary BR. 2 other bedrooms on the second floor are all large enough for whatever they are needed for. Good sized loft is another living area with good size. A large family room with fireplace gives a nice view of the lake. Go out to the garage and notice that although it is 3 bays wide it is actually big enough for 4 vehicles. Walk out of the garage head out towards the lake. Notice the large patio off of the family room, then get to the dock! Huge with outdoor bar, plenty of sitting space and potential for a fire pit. And then take a look at the boat lift. Its like feature after feature keeps presenting itself. Whatever you do don't miss out on this house. Schedule your showing today!!!

Type:
Single Family
Sq.Ft.:
2,522
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Lot size:
0.25 Acres
Year built:
1995
Baths:
3.00
MLS#:
21995425
Subdivision:
Morse Landing

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

A rare find, this spacious 4 BR 2.5 BATH two story is one of the largest floor plans in Morse Landing. Featuring well equipped kitchen/Breakfast areas. Open to large family room with fireplace, and built ins. Formal living room connects to dining room for those large gatherings. Lovely Master bedroom suite with large walk in closet, double sinks, whirlpool tub and separate shower. Good sized secondary BRS plus 21x20 rec/play room including hot tub, just off family room w access to back yard. In addition there is an abundance of storage areas including huge attic space over garage. Enjoy the evenings on your private back patio in private fenced well landscaped back yard. Convenient to Morse Lake, schools, parks, golf + entertainment.

Type:
Duplex
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
Beds:
n/a
Year built:
1969
Baths:
MLS#:
21974611
Subdivision:
Washington Glass

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Investor opportunity! Duplex in Cicero, IN is ready for a new investor. This property is a brick ranch duplex just South of McDonald's on S.R. 19. Unit A is occupied with a recently renewed lease. The bedrooms are carpet, and there is vinyl throughout the rest of the apartment. Unit B is being turned over and will be for rent shortly. There are vinyl plank floors in the bedrooms and vinyl through the remainder. Each apartment had a recent kitchen upgrade and new back/front concrete patios have been poured. There is a service agreement in place for the HVAC systems. The technicians check and clean the systems twice a year. Don't miss out.

Type:
Duplex
Sq.Ft.:
n/a
Status:
Active
Beds:
n/a
Year built:
1984
Baths:
MLS#:
21975740
Subdivision:
Washington Glass

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Investor opportunity! Duplex in Cicero, IN is ready for a new investor. This property is a ranch duplex with vinyl siding just West of CVS. Unit A and B are occupied. Each apartment's 2 bedrooms and the living rooms have carpet and vinyl throughout the rest. There is a service agreement in place for the HVAC systems. The technicians check and clean the systems twice a year.

Type:
Manufactured Home
Sq.Ft.:
910
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.11 Acres
Year built:
2023
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
21919455
Subdivision:
Hidden Bay

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

INVESTORS!! Great investment opportunity to add to portfolio!! Move in ready! OPTION FOR DOCK LEASE! ** MOTIVATED SELLER! Looking for a peaceful retreat by the water? Look no further than this BRAND NEW 3 bed 2 bath home with water access on beautiful Morse Reservoir. Open concept living room & kitchen, primary en suite, and custom touches throughout! Mature trees, wooded lot with views of Morse Lake. Water access from back of lot to Morse Lake for fishing or kayak launching! You will love the charm of the quaint town of Cicero. Great restaurants and music on the water!

Type:
Manufactured Home
Sq.Ft.:
910
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Lot size:
0.11 Acres
Year built:
2023
Baths:
2.00
MLS#:
21918322
Subdivision:
Hidden Bay

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

INVESTORS!! Great investment opportunity to add to portfolio!! Move in ready! OPTION FOR DOCK LEASE! ** MOTIVATED SELLER! Looking for a peaceful retreat by the water? Look no further than this BRAND NEW 3 bed 2 bath home with water access on beautiful Morse Reservoir. Open concept living room & kitchen, primary en suite, and custom touches throughout! Mature trees, wooded lot with views of Morse Lake. Water access from back of lot to Morse Lake for fishing or kayak launching! You will love the charm of the quaint town of Cicero. Great restaurants and music on the water!

Refine Property Search
Page 1 of 1    Prev | Next
1–20 of 20 properties displayed

Albert Wright Page, License RB14038157, Xome Inc., License RC51300094, [email protected], 844-400-XOME (9663), 4471 North Billman Estates, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Listings courtesy of MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of {{last updated}}. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS. © 2024 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®. All Rights Reserved.

How may I help you?

Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent





Send Request

We respect your privacy