Shelter Island NY Homes for Sale
$1,499,000
5 Wade Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- 1,854
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- 3
- Year built:
- 1967
- Baths:
- 3.00
- MLS#:
- 825119
View additional info
Courtesy: Signature Premier Properties
516-741-4333
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Situated far back from the road and offering privacy and tranquility, a long driveway leads to this move-in ready, super comfortable expanded ranch nestled on a landscaped .62-acre lot and loaded with updates ~ A spacious tiled entry hall welcomes you into the home and leads you to the open-concept main area ~ Gleaming quartz counters add a stylish touch to a well-equipped kitchen complete with stainless steel appliances ~ The combined living and dining rooms offer a great flow, and sliders to the generous back deck make indoor/outdoor entertaining a breeze ~ The home was extended to offer a huge primary bedroom ensuite boasting cathedral ceilings, a dressing area with walk-in closet, and a spacious private bathroom with oversized shower, soaking tub, toilet room and two vanities ~ Two additional bedrooms with double closets, a full guest bathroom and beautifully maintained hardwood floors complete the 1,854 sq. ft. main level ~ The lower level expands the living space 480+/- sq. ft. with a semi-above-ground den featuring a cozy and convenient propane fireplace, tile floors, sliders to a lovely bluestone patio with pergola, a new wet bar, a stylish new bathroom with stall shower, and access to a huge, full basement offering tons of storage, laundry area and utilities ~ Outside, a secluded yard boasts a large deck with plenty of room for dining and comfy seating, another bluestone patio perfect for a fire pit, and an above-ground hot tub/swim spa with resistance current and underwater treadmill ~ Other bonuses include a renovated garage with brand new flooring and a whole-house generator that automatically starts up when the power goes out ~ For those considering a purchase for investment purposes, this home has a great rental history with wonderful repeat summer tenants ~ Located steps away from a nature preserve, this residence ideally situated just a short ride to town, North Ferry, beaches, restaurants, shops and everything else Shelter Island living has to offer ~
$889,990
5 Marc St Shelter Island, NY 11964
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- n/a
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- n/a
- Lot size:
- 0.5 Acres
- Year built:
- 2008
- Baths:
- MLS#:
- 825050
View additional info
Courtesy: RE/MAX Signature Real Estate
631-941-4111
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
2 Story New Construction ready for investor to complete. Sold "AS IS' Cash. Completed Value $2+Mil..Survey and town docs available,
$5,700,000
90 Peconic Ave Shelter Is Ht, NY 11964
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- 3,325
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- 5
- Lot size:
- 1 Acres
- Year built:
- 1985
- Baths:
- 4.00
- MLS#:
- 811480
- Subdivision:
- Silver Beach
View additional info
Courtesy: Susan C Cincotta
631-514-9891
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Value, Location and Style adorn this Rare Waterfront Green Lawns Gem on gorgeous Shelter Island. Available after 100 years of property ownership. The 190' of Silver Beach waterfront is fully bulk headed with dock on a level acre with generous side lawn. Perfect for entertaining or escaping as it's surrounded by mature landscaping. Reich Eklund custom built this jewel of a beach house in 1985 and it is well designed and maintained by one owner. All rooms have waterviews including main, living , dining and bedrooms with waterviews from 2 or 3 sides and all facing the magnificent waterfront sunsets and sea breeze. This Nantucket Shingle Classic with room for pool has 5 waterview bedrooms (2 en suite) 3.5 baths, full waterside balcony, boasts an open floor plan, 2 car attached garage, laundry room and full basement with poured concrete foundation and bilco door. If you are searching for a carefree, relaxing and magical lifestyle on the waterfront. This might very well be it!
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- 5,300
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- 4
- Year built:
- 2007
- Baths:
- 5.00
- MLS#:
- L3592958
- Subdivision:
- Foley Estate
View additional info
Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
631-537-5900
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Quintessential Hamptons estate in the heart of Shelter Island . Enjoy the best of both worlds at this traditional Hamptons style home, with approximately 5000sqft of immaculate living space across one level, and nearly an acre of land, it's the perfect setting for the best of year round and seamless indoor-outdoor living. The custom-built home welcomes you with its vaulted ceiling in the foyer, and opens up to its oversized living room with wood burning fireplace. The eat-in chefs' kitchen is outfitted with large island and granite countertops, high end luxury appliances, wet bar and breakfast area leading out to the patio. Nearly every room in the house enjoys direct access to the rear courtyard with patio, heated gunite pool, and wood burning fireplace. The ensuite primary bedroom and full guest suite with living room, kitchenette, and its own wood burning fireplace, bookend the home with their own wing to further the estate feel and maximize privacy and functionality of this thoughtful layout, with two other ensuite bedrooms in between. There is room for expansion in every direction. Nearly all appliances and mechanicals are new or like new under the care of the current and fastidious owner. Enjoy everything both North and South Forks have to offer and the magic of Shelter Island, at this centrally located home. In close proximity to the best beaches, restaurants and more., Additional information: Appearance:Diamond,Interior Features:Guest Quarters,Marble Bath
$1,875,000
8 Tims Trl Shelter Is Ht, NY 11964
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- 3,689
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- 4
- Lot size:
- 0.62 Acres
- Year built:
- 2023
- Baths:
- 5.00
- MLS#:
- 801164
View additional info
Courtesy: HomeCoin.com
888-400-2513
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Situated in a quiet neighborhood, just a 5 minute stroll from West Neck Bay, and Bootlegger Alley Beach. This 4 bedroom, 4.5 bath room home is turnkey and ready for your decorator! The home features 4 ensuite bedrooms with room for King-sized beds. The open floor plans includes a custom modern European kitchen with LP gas range and 8' island facing a dining and living room with wood burning fireplace. A wall of 8' tall glass sliding doors open up to an expansive mahogany deck and private yard. The lower level is finished with 9' ceilings and glass sliding doors opening up to an areaway and OSE with lots of natural light. A separate single car garage with aluminum and glass door has plenty of attic storage! Finished with wide plank European white oak floors, Andersen Windows, Fiber Cement, and Mahogany siding. Seller will provide pool permit assistance.
$2,990,000
5 Bay Shore Dr Shelter Is Ht, NY 11964
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- 1,500
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- 3
- Year built:
- 1954
- Baths:
- 2.00
- MLS#:
- L3590276
View additional info
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
631-749-1155
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
This waterfront home with deep water dock is a boater's dream. A cozy beach home featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a 2 car garage, and outdoor shower, all tucked down a quiet dead-end road, in the sought after Silver Beach area. Enjoy breathtaking sunrises from this spacious yard overlooking West Neck Creek, and a nature preserve. This wonderful home is near the most desirable beaches on Shelter Island., Additional information: Interior Features:Lr/Dr
$5,995,000
8 Cove Way Shelter Island, NY 11964
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- n/a
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- 4
- Year built:
- 1998
- Baths:
- 5.00
- MLS#:
- L3578053
View additional info
Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
631-725-0200
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
This stunning, fully renovated waterfront home features 4 bedrooms and 5 baths, with year-round blooming gardens. It boasts 113 feet of waterfront, a stone patio with a firepit, and a Gunite heated pool surrounded by lush landscaping for privacy. Perched on a bluff, winding stairs lead to a dock with 4.5 feet at low tide. The home includes two primary suites with water views, two guest suites, a living room with cathedral ceilings, a large kitchen and dining area, a full bath, and a media room. All rooms offer views of the stone patio and water. Ready for immediate move-in. Schedule a viewing soon.
$3,475,000
156 Ram Island Dr Shelter Island, NY 11964
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- 3,420
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- 4
- Year built:
- 1995
- Baths:
- 4.00
- MLS#:
- L3577201
View additional info
Courtesy: Corcoran
631-288-6900
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Surrounded by preserved land this classic home has an absolutely magnificent setting that includes stunning water views. The open kitchen, breakfast room and family room creates a comfortable bright living area that walks out to a lovely patio overlooking Gardiners Bay . The more formal dining and living room with fireplace also provides amazing views of the water. The spacious primary bedroom with balcony is as dreamy as the view, which is truly incredible. An oversized bath and additional upper-level bedroom complete this private owner's area. Two main level bedrooms serviced by a full bath will accommodate family and friends beautifully. A two-car garage and studio with a half bath is a great place to set up your game room or home office. A full basement with high ceilings can be finished to incorporate an exercise or workout room. Lush landscaping with charming stone walls on 1.90 acres completes this peaceful location. Finished Square Footage 3420 includes the Studio.
$7,950,000
7 Westmoreland Dr Shelter Is Ht, NY 11964
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- 4,957
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- 6
- Year built:
- 1901
- Baths:
- 5.00
- MLS#:
- L3567654
View additional info
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
631-749-1155
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Step into a piece of history with this beautifully restored Tudor home, originally built in 1901. Meticulously maintained and updated with modern amenities, this 6-bedroom, 4.5-bathroom residence offers the perfect blend of classic charm and contemporary comfort. Inside, you'll find 6 stunning fireplaces, each equipped with heatilators for efficient warmth. The original plaster has been carefully restored, preserving the home's historic character. New heating and central air conditioning systems ensure year-round comfort, while additional insulation on the second and third floors provides energy efficiency. A chef's dream, the kitchen has been completely renovated and features a newly added butler's pantry. Outside, the property boasts a heated 20x50 Gunite pool and hot tub, perfect for entertaining and relaxation. A classic brick patio complements the elegant surroundings, and a deep water dock accommodates multiple boats, making this the ideal waterfront retreat
$2,399,000
5 Hager Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- 3,312
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- 3
- Year built:
- 1962
- Baths:
- 3.00
- MLS#:
- L3564455
View additional info
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
631-749-1155
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Experience the epitome of coastal living in this meticulously maintained one-level home, nestled in a charming beach community. Renovated in 2012 by Fokine Construction, this stunning residence offers breathtaking water views of Menantic Creek from nearly every room. Inside, you'll find an open-concept floor plan featuring a vaulted living room with a cozy fireplace, a dining area, and a custom chef's kitchen. Step outside onto the waterside deck, adorned with mahogany railings and stainless wire, for a serene outdoor retreat. The primary bedroom is a true oasis, complete with two walk-in closets and a luxurious en-suite bathroom. Enjoy the tranquility of the 1.29-acre shared parcel extending into the creek. This quiet enclave offers the perfect blend of luxury and natural beauty, making it an ideal coastal retreat. Some of the exterior photos with white siding have been virtually altered.
$2,390,000
4 Irene Ln Shelter Island, NY 11964
- Type:
- Single Family
- Sq.Ft.:
- 2,600
- Status:
- Active
- Beds:
- 4
- Year built:
- 1966
- Baths:
- 3.00
- MLS#:
- L3543543
View additional info
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
631-749-1155
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Discover a serene sanctuary amidst the natural beauty of Shelter Island. This stunning residence offers breathtaking water views of Miss Annie's Creek, providing an unparalleled escape from the ordinary. Step onto the property and be captivated by the charm of covered porches and a heated pool, inviting you to relax and soak in the picturesque vistas. Whether you're enjoying a quiet morning coffee or hosting unforgettable gatherings, this waterfront oasis provides the perfect backdrop for every occasion. Don't miss this opportunity to own a piece of paradise in Mashomack Preserve.
Listings courtesy of One Key MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 11/13/2024. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS. Per New York legal requirement, click here for the Standard Operating Procedures. Copyright 2025, OneKey MLS, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Shelter Island Real Estate
The median home value in Shelter Island, NY is $1,875,000. This is higher than the county median home value of $565,700. The national median home value is $338,100. The average price of homes sold in Shelter Island, NY is $1,875,000. Approximately 44.36% of Shelter Island homes are owned, compared to 3.9% rented, while 51.75% are vacant. Shelter Island real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Shelter Island real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Shelter Island, New York 11964 has a population of 3,661. Shelter Island 11964 is less family-centric than the surrounding county with 15.69% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 32.94%.
The median household income in Shelter Island, New York 11964 is $100,094. The median household income for the surrounding county is $111,660 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Shelter Island 11964 is 51.3 years.
Shelter Island Weather
The average high temperature in July is 80.7 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 23.1 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 48.2 inches per year, with 26.2 inches of snow per year.