BLAST FROM THE PAST! Solid mixed use building features three recently upgraded/ painted apartments PLUS walk back in time through the Lower Level former Damascene College Bookstore! Walk through and it is just as it was- and has potential for future occupancy, City of Oneonta MU-2 Mixed Use zone! Parking is limited, but with some creativity this building could be once again producing 4 incomes! Apartments are charming, neat. and clean. On-site laundry fOR tenants! This solid rental building must be seen! Apt 1: 1 bedroom 1 bath. Living room, kitchen, bedroom and bath- 3 room. Flooring is carpet and vinyl. Refrigerator and range. $650 mo plus electric, 400 sf- unoccupied. Apt 2: 1 bedroom 1 bath. Living room, kitchen, bedroom, and bath- 3 room apartment. Carpet and vinyl flooring. $650 a month plus electric.450 sf- Floor 1- unoccupied. Apt 3: 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom. Living room, kitchen, 2 bedrooms and bath. 4 room apartment. $650 plus electric- 600 sf- Floor 2- occupied. Commercial unit- Basement level, 700 sg ft, unoccupied.
Prime Storefront Opportunity at 128 Chestnut St, Oneonta, NY! Seize the chance to establish your business in a vibrant and bustling area of Oneonta. This property offers: Versatile Space: A 420-square-foot area suitable for various business types. Historic Charm: Built in 1900, this building combines classic architecture with modern amenities and has recently been refreshed. Convenient Location: Situated in a high-traffic area, your business will benefit from excellent visibility and accessibility. Don't miss this opportunity to position your business in a prime location. Contact us today to schedule a viewing and explore the potential of 128 Chestnut St.
DESTINATION LOCATION This former nursery and landscape business location of 2,200 square feet plus 2,500 square feet of hard-scape walkways, and open/covered patios is turn-key ready including an operating greenhouse, underground water/electric, and ample yard space! Owner has recently completed major upgrades to both interior and exterior!!! If you are seeking a unique indoor and outdoor venue for restaurant, coffee shop, cafe, or brewery...look no further! The indoor greenhouse room, large finished service/retail rooms, conference room, offices, and bath are all in place, and are ideal to create a working kitchen environment and the perfect flow of indoor to outdoor seating/fire-pit/music venue! Country-like atmosphere meets a 5 minute drive to I88, downtown, and the Cooperstown All Star Village! If you want living space as well, the 850 square foot BRAND NEW upscale 2nd floor apartment with deck features a cathedral ceiling 'great room", two bedrooms and bath and a half. Call today to view this property sitting on 1,3 acres in the city ;limits of Oneonta, NY!
Business block opportunity! Positioned nicely across the street from the center square of downtown known as Muller Plaza. Six figure cash-flow can be yours at this versatile downtown building! Long-time first floor eatery anchors the address, and four upscale three bedroom apartments on second and third floors provide an additional 12 beds of income! Easy care building- just manage your income opportunity! On-site laundry is provided for residential tenants. Do not miss this opportunity to grow your net income steadily year by year!
Incredible investment opportunity! This historic building on Main St in Oneonta includes six residential units and three commercial rentals. There is also an additional 1,600-square-foot flex space with its own entrance that can serve as another residential or commercial rental. Tenants pay all utilities. The opportunity to own a well-maintained, fully rented building in historic Downtown Oneonta does not come around often, don't let this one pass you by!
6 UNITS, 16 BEDROOMS, 7 BATHROOMS! GREAT LOCATION, solid rental history, close to both colleges, a block to bus stop, great parking, short walk to Main Street. 3 two bedrooms, 2 three bedrooms, 1 four bedroom, all furnished. Boiler new 2010. Common laundry in basement, as well as 2 laundry areas upstairs (new 2017 & 2023). COC in place. Includes 2 parcels, 2nd tax map# 288.17-3-16. RENTS: Apt 1- 12 month lease, $1000 month, 2 bedrooms, rented thru 7/31/24. Apt 2 - $3600 per student/per semester, 2 bedrooms, rented for 23-24. Apt 3 - $3600 per student/per semester, 3 bedrooms. (1 bedroom was vacant fall 2023, 2 bedrooms are vacant Spring 2024, Apt 4 - $3600 per student/per semester, 2 bedrooms, rented 2023-24. Apt 5 - $3600 per student/per semester, 3 bedrooms, rented 2023-24. Apt 6 - $3250 per student/per semester, 4 bedrooms, vacant until March-rented for 2 months @$1200 per month. 2023 Income was $93,238, Expenses were $76,860. 2023 expenses include new laundry area and new sewer line to the street along with other improvements. The 2022 income was $100,865, expenses were $49,470. The 2021 Income was $124,624. 2021 expenses were $62,190. EXPENSES include a 10% management fee.
Introducing downtown Oneonta's (NY) top contender for preservation and repurposing. This solid, historic, well-cared-for 3-story brick building with approximately 9000 sq ft of finished space, is perfectly poised for creative enterprise! Consider redeveloping as executive offices, a music, artistic, or business incubator, apartments, or a mixed-use building with street-level retail or restaurant space. Zoned for mixed-use, the building is eligible for historic renovation tax credits. The first & second floors now feature (13) move-in ready offices, sound-proof studios, suites, conference rooms and (2) half baths & (1) full. The finished basement is a spacious hall with a full kitchen, (2) additional offices, and dry storage. A tour of the third floor will get your creative juices flowing! Awaiting your vision is a large open ballroom (including a wardrobe room and ½ bath) that features high tin ceilings, period light fixtures, and natural wood trim and floors. Updated heating, air conditioning, plumbing and electrical systems. DON’T MISS this incredible opportunity to invest in downtown Oneonta’s renaissance!
![]() |
© 2025 Greater Capital Association of REALTORS (CRMLSNY). All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website have been downloaded from CRMLS. The IDX logo indicates listings of other real estate firms that are identified in the detailed listing information. Information herein is deemed reliable but not guaranteed, representations are approximate, individual verification's recommended. Per New York legal requirement, click here for the Standard Operating Procedures. |
The median home value in Oneonta, NY is $220,467. This is higher than the county median home value of $187,700. The national median home value is $338,100. The average price of homes sold in Oneonta, NY is $220,467. Approximately 38.74% of Oneonta homes are owned, compared to 40.99% rented, while 20.26% are vacant. Oneonta real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Oneonta real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Oneonta, New York has a population of 12,764. Oneonta is less family-centric than the surrounding county with 21.07% of the households containing married families with children. The county average for households married with children is 24%.
The median household income in Oneonta, New York is $58,499. The median household income for the surrounding county is $60,523 compared to the national median of $69,021. The median age of people living in Oneonta is 21.9 years.
The average high temperature in July is 78.3 degrees, with an average low temperature in January of 12.1 degrees. The average rainfall is approximately 41.7 inches per year, with 82.6 inches of snow per year.